A blue hardside suitcase standing on a wooden floor
Travel Gear

Carry-On Luggage Compared: Away, Samsonite, Briggs & Riley and More

A buyer's guide to carry-on suitcases: hardside vs softside, wheels, zips, size rules and how the big luggage brands compare on warranty and durability.

In this article

A good carry-on suitcase quietly makes travel easier for years. A bad one snaps a wheel in the first airport corridor. Because luggage takes real abuse, the difference between brands often shows up over time rather than in the showroom, which makes shopping for it surprisingly tricky.

Here’s a practical framework for choosing, plus how the major names compare.

Get the size right first

Airline rules are strict and vary. A commonly used carry-on size for many US airlines is about 22 x 14 x 9 inches (56 x 36 x 23 cm), including wheels and handles, but budget carriers often allow less, and weight limits apply in many regions. Before buying, check the size and weight rules for the airlines you fly most, especially low-cost ones.

Many people also buy a slightly smaller case to be safe, then rely on packing cubes to make the most of the space.

Hardside or softside?

HardsideSoftside
ProtectionBetter against crushing and rainFabric can absorb impacts; resists scratching
FlexibilityRigid shell, clamshell openingSqueezes into tight spaces; pockets on the outside
WearShows scuffs and can crack in extreme cold or heavy impactCan stain or fray over time
Best forFragile items, wet weatherBusiness travel, overstuffed trips

The shell material matters. Polycarbonate is generally more flexible and impact-resistant than ABS, which is stiffer and can crack; blends and aluminium exist at different price points.

The parts that fail first

When luggage breaks, it’s usually one of these:

  1. Wheels. Look for smooth, replaceable spinner wheels (four wheels) or sturdy inline wheels (two wheels). Two-wheel designs are often more durable and easier to control over rough ground; spinners glide effortlessly in airports.
  2. Handles. A telescoping handle should lock firmly at multiple heights without rattling.
  3. Zips. Look for robust, well-known zip hardware and reinforced stitching where the zip meets the corners.
  4. Corners and feet. Reinforced corners protect the shell in the most common impact spots.

How the brands compare

BrandKnown forWarranty approachGood fit for
AwayClean design and thoughtful features aimed at modern travellersLimited lifetime warranty with terms to reviewStyle-conscious frequent travellers
SamsoniteHuge range at many price pointsWarranty terms vary by model and regionBuyers wanting choice and availability
Briggs & RileyBusiness-focused durability and a strong repair reputationWell-known lifetime guarantee that covers performance issuesFrequent flyers who want long-term value
RimowaIconic aluminium and polycarbonate casesPremium price; check service optionsBuyers valuing heritage and design
TumiBusiness and premium travel gearWarranty and repair options varyProfessionals who travel constantly
Delsey and TravelproPractical mid-range choices, with Travelpro popular among aircrewVaries by modelBuyers wanting good value

Always read the current warranty for the exact model you’re buying. Terms can differ by region and product line, and exclusions for airline damage are common.

Inspect wheels, zips and handles before you buy; they're the parts that fail first.
Inspect wheels, zips and handles before you buy; they're the parts that fail first.

Features worth paying for

  • A removable battery pack (if any). Some cases include a battery for charging; many airlines require it to be removable so you can carry it separately. Check current airline rules.
  • Compression or divider systems that make packing easier.
  • Lockable zips. Useful when you’re checking bags.
  • A laptop compartment, if you travel for work.

Features you can skip

  • Built-in scales, GPS trackers and speakers, which add cost and potential failure points. A separate luggage tag, tracker and travel scale do the job.

Look after it

Wipe down hardside shells and spot-clean fabric, avoid overstuffing so zips aren’t stressed, and check the wheels before every trip. A few minutes of care extends life considerably.

Consider the total cost

Buying a durable case once is usually cheaper than replacing a budget one every couple of years. Think about how often you fly, how roughly your luggage is handled and how valuable repair support is to you. If you fly a few times a year, a solid mid-range suitcase is plenty; if you’re on the road most weeks, spending more on repairable, well-supported luggage pays off.

Bottom line: choose the right size for your airlines, inspect wheels, zips and handles, and favour brands with strong warranties and repair services over flashy features.

FAQ

Are expensive suitcases worth it?

If you travel often, yes, especially when the price buys better components and a repair programme. For occasional travellers, a good mid-range case is usually enough.

Should I choose two wheels or four?

Four-wheel spinners are easier to manoeuvre through airports. Two-wheel cases are usually sturdier over rough terrain and take less space in the bin.

Can I bring a suitcase with a battery on a plane?

Rules vary by airline and country. Many require lithium batteries to be removable and carried in the cabin. Check with your airline before you fly.

Independence note: Wordzex doesn’t take payment for coverage. Specifications, prices and availability change often, so check the manufacturer’s current details before you buy. Read how we work in our editorial policy.

Written by

Hannah Whitfield

Outdoors, Travel & Mobility Writer

Hannah writes about gear that has to perform away from home — on trails, in airports and on the road — and about brands that back it with real repair programmes.

More from Hannah →